That’s an interesting one. Our club doesn’t make a point of doing club quests, if we happen to complete one great, but when the tribute quest comes up that one is mandatory for our team.
So sometimes the quest expires, once someone hits dismiss the next one in line starts, I’ve had a quest that expired and we didn’t get, and I myself didn’t hit dismiss, when I finally hit dismissed, the next one was already completed and I did not contribute so I didn’t get anything, by clicking ok, it took me to the next active quest.
If every person in the club is not dismissing a quest I don’t actually know what happens. Perhaps you fall behind in quests? It’s an interesting question, and I hope my information has shed some light for you!