Island Storytime: Who was YOUR first Celebrity Crush?

Leave your comments below for a chance at being randomly picked to receive 25K Coins and 5 Wilds! Next Thursday we will choose 10 players at random, plus the person who posts our favorite answer! (11 in total).

Mine was Kim Richards. I was very young, and she starred in a short-lived drama called Nanny and the Professor. My crush lasted through the Escape to Witch Mountain movies, and then One Day at a Time aired, and I fell pretty hard for Valerie Bertinelli.

I guess you always have a thing for your first celebrity crush, but I wouldn’t say I harbor any real feelings for either of them, although I’d love to have lunch with Valerie.



Brad Pitt when i saw for the first time Troy. Today i only think it is a cool guy and a good actor.


It would be a toss up between Troy Donahue or Peter Noone of Herman’s Hermits. It has been so long I may have his name wrong. I thought they were both so dreamy!


Johnny Depp watched every 21 Jump Street and everything he’s been in with the exception of most of the Pirates of the Cararribean


Shaun Cassidy!!


My first celebrity crush was Matt Dillon in the 80’s. I had posters of him on my wall.


Stephen King, lol was a horror freak early on

Mel Gibson oh yeah, Lethal Weapon or Forever Young orrrrrrrr…lol

Zach Morris on saved by the bell or Donnie Wahlberg of New kids

Tom Selleck. I had Magnum PI posters all over my walls!

Davy Jones of The Monkees.


Shaun Cassidy was my first celebrity crush.

1 Like

Johnny Weismuller as Tarzan.

Ayrton Senna, il più grande e indimenticato campione di F1. Muore giovane chi è caro agli dei…

1 Like

Scott Baio from happy days then Charles in Charge the good old classics they don’t make them like they used too!!! No I don’t have a crush on him now it’s George Clooney

Tom Hanks :heart_eyes::heart_eyes: Willlllllsooooooon



Richard Gere

Mine would have to be Jonathan Taylor Thomas :heart_eyes:. Then my teenage years would definitely be Brian Littrell from the Backstreet Boys!!!

1 Like

My first celebrity crush was David Cassidy.

Hawkeye Pierce (aka Alan alda) in MASH